Samarium Iron Nitride (SmFeN) materials and Neodymium Iron Boron (NdFeB) materials are both common rare earth permanent magnet materials used in the manufacture of strong magnetic magnets, and while they have similar properties in some areas, they differ significantly in others, so whether or not they can be substituted depends on the specific application requirements.

Here are some comparisons between samarium iron nitride and neodymium iron boron materials:

Magnetic properties: NdFeB is currently recognized as one of the permanent magnet materials with the highest magnetic energy product (a key indicator of magnetic properties). It has excellent magnetic properties and is therefore widely used in many applications, including electric motors, generators, electric cars, audio equipment, etc. The magnetic properties of Samarium Iron Nitride are relatively low and usually not comparable to NdFeB.

Thermal Stability: Samarium Iron Nitride has better stability at high temperatures compared to NdFeB, which makes it a potentially better choice for high temperature environments, or for applications that require high temperature resistance.

Magnetic material cost: Comparatively speaking, the raw material cost of Samarium Iron Nitride is low, only about half of NdFeB, because it does not contain rare earth elements such as neodymium, while NdFeB contains rare neodymium elements, which affects the cost to a certain extent.

In summary, samarium-iron nitride materials can replace NdFeB in certain specific applications, especially where high temperature stability, lower cost, or extremely high magnetic properties are not required. However, in applications where very high magnetic properties are required, such as high performance motors and generators, NdFeB is still the permanent magnet material of choice. The choice depends on the specific application requirements and weighing the performance and cost of different materials.

The graph below shows the theoretical magnetic properties of different rare-earth permanent magnet materials, including SmFeN.

More about magnet materials;

Rare Earth Neodymium Magnets vs Samarium Cobalt Magnets

Neodymium Magnets vs Ferrite Magnets